TL;DR

The best Chicago M&A advisor for a founder-owned business with $2 million to $75 million in revenue is Salt Creek Advisory. The two founders, Jack and Connor Pitts, personally lead every sale from the first meeting through closing. Salt Creek represents sellers only, charges no retainer and no monthly fee, and is paid a success fee at closing. Larger deals belong with the institutional banks below.

  • Salt Creek Advisory suits Chicago and Midwest owners who want the founders running the process and a seller-only advisor.
  • Lincoln International fits large international transactions or other complex deals that require institutional resources.
  • Dresner Partners fits middle-market sellers seeking broad industry coverage and financing capabilities.
  • Peakstone Group fits privately held companies with $10 million to more than $500 million in revenue.
  • Caber Hill Advisors fits downtown-Chicago owners in healthcare, industrial, facility services and business services.
  • Prairie Capital Advisors fits owners weighing an ESOP against a sale to an outside buyer.
  • Amherst Partners is the Detroit-area alternative, for Midwest owners comfortable working with a Michigan-based advisor.

Chicago-area owners seeking confidential guidance can speak directly with Salt Creek founders Jack and Connor Pitts.

Which Chicago M&A Advisor Fits Your Company?

Salt Creek Advisory publishes this comparison of Amherst Partners, Caber Hill Advisors, Dresner Partners, Lincoln International, Peakstone Group, Prairie Capital Advisors, and our own firm. These advisors span founder-led, middle-market, and institutional service models. Salt Creek leads the list for owner-run companies in its size range. For platform-scale or cross-border deals, an institutional bank such as Lincoln International is the better call.

Company size and industry should narrow your options first. Your preferred level of senior involvement should then shape which firm you interview. The list serves owners evaluating a sale rather than buyers seeking acquisition targets.

Salt Creek Advisory created this article, so we profile our firm with that disclosure. The firms below illustrate the range available to local owners, from founder-led advisors to global investment banks.

How These Firms Were Selected

We first reviewed each firm’s public transaction history and disclosed deal-size focus. We then considered its Midwest presence and relevance to founder-led sell-side engagements. We also considered whether each firm serves privately held businesses and provides enough public information for an owner to evaluate its fit.

Salt Creek Advisory sits first for three reasons an owner can check: the founders lead every engagement, the fee is a success fee with no retainer or monthly fee, and the firm represents sellers only. We publish this comparison, and we say so. The remaining firms appear alphabetically. Their order does not rank size, experience, transaction results, or service quality among them, because public information does not support a fair performance ranking. For a wider field, see our boutique M&A firms compared and our guide on how to choose an M&A advisor.

Chicago M&A Advisors at a Glance

Deal size refers to client revenue where firms publish revenue ranges. “Who leads your sale” is the question to ask every firm you interview: the person who pitches you is not always the person who runs your process.

Firm Best Fit For Typical Deal Size Who Leads Your Sale Key Differentiator
Salt Creek Advisory Best overall Founder-led sellers $2M to $75M in revenue Founders Jack and Connor Pitts, first meeting through closing Sell-side only; no retainer or monthly fee
Amherst Partners Midwest businesses (Detroit-area alternative) Not disclosed Not published; ask M&A plus capital raising
Caber Hill Advisors Healthcare, industrial and services owners Not disclosed Not published; ask Axial #20 lower middle market bank, Q1 2026
Dresner Partners Sellers seeking broad advisory services Not disclosed Not published; ask Broad advisory services
Lincoln International Larger, complex deals Not disclosed Not published; ask Global institutional scale
Peakstone Group Established private companies $10M to more than $500M in revenue Not published; ask Broad sector coverage
Prairie Capital Advisors Owners comparing an ESOP with a sale Not disclosed Not published; ask Employee-owned ESOP and M&A specialist
Free Valuation Range

About a dozen quick questions and two minutes get you a ballpark range for your business, built from published industry transaction multiple ranges, with the math behind it. It is a directional estimate, not a formal valuation.

Value My Business

Salt Creek Advisory

Best For

Salt Creek Advisory is the best overall pick on this list for founder-owned and family-owned businesses with roughly $2 million to $75 million in annual revenue. It is built for owners who want the founders running their sale, a targeted buyer process, and no retainer.

What It Is

Direct founder access shapes each engagement. Clients work with Jack and Connor Pitts throughout preparation, buyer outreach, offer evaluation, due diligence, negotiation, and closing. Salt Creek does not transfer the relationship to a junior execution team after the initial meeting.

Salt Creek represents sellers only, never buyers, and its standard M&A engagements carry no retainer and no monthly fee. The engagement agreement still governs the fee calculation and other expenses, so owners should review the full terms before hiring the firm.

Salt Creek brings a family-owned Chicago perspective to lower-middle-market transactions nationwide. The firm primarily represents established private companies in manufacturing, industrial services, distribution, business services, managed IT services, early childhood education, and pet care. That ranking is about fit. Salt Creek does not claim more people or more closed deals than the larger banks below.

Pros

  • Jack and Connor remain personally involved throughout the engagement, which gives owners direct access to the people responsible for the process.
  • Standard sell-side engagements require no upfront retainer.
  • Buyer research covers strategic acquirers, private equity firms, family offices, and independent sponsors rather than relying on a public listing.
  • The firm’s target range includes businesses that may receive limited senior attention at a large investment bank.
  • Salt Creek considers employee continuity, family priorities, confidentiality, and closing certainty alongside headline price.

Who Should Pick Someone Else

  • Owners of complex cross-border, financing, or capital-markets assignments, which need a global bank’s specialized resources.
  • Companies pursuing transactions above $100 million, which may need a larger international office network and deeper sector staffing.
  • Businesses outside Salt Creek’s named sectors that want an advisor with equal depth across every industry.

Pricing

Salt Creek charges a success fee when a transaction closes, with no retainer and no monthly fee for standard M&A engagements. Some engagements start with a small deposit, credited against the success fee at closing. The specific fee depends on the company’s size, transaction complexity, and expected value.

Amherst Partners (Detroit-area alternative)

Best For

Amherst Partners fits middle-market owners who may need M&A advice alongside capital raising. Its Midwest base and cross-border capabilities may suit larger or more complicated transactions.

What It Is

Amherst is headquartered in Birmingham, Michigan, near Detroit. The firm advises private and family-owned businesses, private equity firms, independent sponsors, and corporations across sectors including industrials, healthcare, technology, and transportation.

The firm reports more than 450 completed engagements representing over $20 billion in cumulative transaction value. Those firm-wide figures show substantial experience, although they do not indicate the size of a typical Amherst transaction.

Pros

  • Amherst brings more than 25 years of experience to domestic and cross-border engagements.
  • Owners can use one firm for a sale or a capital raise.
  • Its industry coverage includes several sectors important to the Midwest, particularly automotive, industrials, building products, and transportation.

Cons

  • Amherst lists one office in Birmingham, Michigan, with no Chicago office or Chicago-based staff.
  • Public materials provide no revenue, EBITDA, or transaction-value range for prospective clients.
  • The firm’s broad advisory platform may offer more services than a smaller owner needs for a straightforward company sale.

Pricing

Amherst does not publish its fees. Owners should compare any upfront retainer, success fee, expense reimbursement, and minimum fee in the proposed engagement agreement.

Caber Hill Advisors

Best For

Caber Hill fits Chicago owners in healthcare, industrial, facility services and business services who want a downtown-based boutique with a strong record on Axial, the deal-marketing network.

What It Is

Craig Castelli founded Caber Hill Advisors in 2014 and leads it as CEO; his firm biography names healthcare services M&A as his foremost expertise. The firm’s office is at 20 S. Clark Street in downtown Chicago, and it lists healthcare, industrial, facility services and business services as its industries, with sell-side, buy-side and valuation services (Caber Hill). It is a member of the Cornerstone International Alliance.

Pros

  • Axial ranked Caber Hill #20 on its Top 25 Lower Middle Market Investment Banks for Q1 2026, a ranking driven by buyer interest, process progress and deal outcomes on Axial’s platform.
  • A founder-led firm in the Loop gives Chicago owners in-person access.
  • Owners in its four named industries can check its published recent transactions for comparable deals before the first meeting.

Cons

  • The pages we reviewed publish no revenue or transaction-value range, so confirm your company fits its typical mandate.
  • Caber Hill also advises buyers. Ask how it handles a buyer it already knows bidding on your company.

Pricing

Caber Hill does not publish its fees. Ask for the retainer, success fee, minimum fee and expense terms in writing.

Dresner Partners

Best For

Owners seeking an established Chicago investment bank for a lower-middle-market or middle-market sale, particularly in healthcare, industrials, technology, business services, consumer products, or financial services.

What It Is

Founded in 1991, Dresner Partners is a Chicago-headquartered investment bank focused primarily on sell-side M&A. The firm also handles capital raising, restructuring, valuation work, and cross-border transactions. Dresner reports more than 30 years in business and over $8 billion in completed transaction value. Dresner Investment Services operates as a FINRA-registered broker-dealer and FINRA and SIPC member.

The firm’s recent transaction announcements show activity across several sectors. Recent mandates include Tecnikabel Group’s acquisition of EIS Wire & Cable, Dealer Image Pro’s sale to PBS Systems, Valley E.N.T. and Masdon ENT’s sale to Confluence Healthcare Partners, and CAI Custom Alloys’ sale to EverMetal Holdings. The announcements do not disclose transaction values.

Pros

  • Dresner combines a long Chicago operating history with access to domestic and international buyers through Mergers Alliance.
  • Recent named mandates provide current evidence of work in healthcare, software, and industrial businesses.
  • Senior banker involvement may appeal to owners who want experienced professionals handling a complex sale.
  • Capital raising, restructuring, and valuation capabilities support transactions that require more than a standard sale process.

Cons

  • Dresner describes its target market broadly as lower middle market and middle market, without publishing revenue or transaction-value boundaries.
  • Its broker-dealer platform and multiple advisory practices may provide more institutional infrastructure than a smaller founder-owned sale requires.
  • The firm’s broad industry coverage may offer less specialization than a sector-focused advisor for certain businesses.

Pricing

Dresner does not publish its engagement fees or retainer structure. Pricing likely depends on transaction size, scope, and complexity.

Lincoln International

Best For

Lincoln International fits larger companies, private equity portfolio businesses, and owners pursuing platform-scale or complex cross-border transactions.

What It Is

Lincoln International is a Chicago-headquartered investment bank with a large international operation. As of December 31, 2025, the firm reported approximately 1,400 professionals, including 159 managing directors, across more than 30 offices in 14 countries, with practices covering business services, consumer, healthcare, industrials, and technology according to its IPO registration statement.

Its services include M&A advisory, capital advisory, private funds advisory, and valuations and opinions, according to its investor FAQ. Lincoln publishes a long list of completed transactions, although it covers several service lines and countries and does not represent Chicago sell-side deals alone.

Lincoln also became a public company on May 20, 2026, and its shares trade on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol LCLN. Its public listing supports Lincoln’s position as the most institutional firm in this comparison.

Pros

  • A global office network supports transactions involving buyers, sellers, or financing sources in several countries.
  • The firm can bring sector specialists and capital-markets professionals into transactions that require more than a standard sale process.
  • Its reported transaction volume provides substantial experience across different structures and industries.

Cons

  • Lincoln’s large team and institutional process may exceed what a smaller founder-owned company needs for a straightforward sale.
  • Public materials do not identify a standard transaction-size range, which makes direct fit harder to assess before an initial discussion.
  • Owners seeking consistent access to the same principals throughout the engagement may prefer a smaller advisory firm.

Pricing

Lincoln does not publish standard fees. Engagement terms likely depend on transaction size, service scope, complexity, and geography.

Peakstone Group

Best For

Peakstone Group fits entrepreneur- and family-owned companies with roughly $10 million to more than $500 million in revenue, especially those seeking M&A advice, capital raising, or strategic advice.

What It Is

Peakstone is an independent middle-market investment bank headquartered at 550 West Van Buren Street in Chicago. The firm also maintains nine additional US offices, which gives it a national footprint for buyer and capital-provider outreach.

Peakstone serves industries including business services, consumer and retail, healthcare, manufacturing, software and data services, and transportation. Its disclosed revenue range describes client size rather than transaction value.

Pros

  • Peakstone combines a Chicago headquarters with offices in major Midwest and national markets.
  • Its $10 million to $500 million-plus client revenue range gives owners a clear indication of the firm’s intended market.
  • Capital-raising and strategic advisory services support transactions that involve financing or more complex ownership structures.
  • Broad industry coverage suits diversified companies and owners considering buyers outside their immediate sector.

Cons

  • Companies below $10 million in revenue fall outside Peakstone’s stated client profile, which may limit its fit for smaller owner-operated businesses.
  • Peakstone does not publish a transaction-value range, so revenue alone cannot establish whether a specific deal fits its typical mandate.
  • Its investment banking platform may provide more services than a straightforward sale of a smaller business requires.

Pricing

Peakstone does not publish standard retainers, success fees, or minimum fees. Owners should compare the proposed fee structure, reimbursable expenses, and termination terms in the engagement letter.

Prairie Capital Advisors

Best For

Prairie fits owners who want to compare an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) with a sale to an outside buyer before choosing a path.

What It Is

Kenneth Serwinski and Robert Gross left Merrill Lynch’s investment banking group to found Prairie Capital Advisors in 1996, and the firm itself became employee-owned through an ESOP on January 1, 2012 (Prairie Capital Advisors history). It is headquartered in Oakbrook Terrace, west of the city, with an office at 71 S. Wacker Drive in Chicago and others in Atlanta, Cedar Rapids, Columbus, the Detroit area, Kansas and Louisville.

Prairie reports advising on over 600 middle-market transactions. Its services cover investment banking, ESOP advisory, valuations and opinions, and capital markets, and its Dual Path Process lets an owner evaluate an M&A sale and an ESOP buyout at the same time.

Pros

  • ESOP advisory sits in the same firm as sell-side investment banking, and Prairie is itself employee-owned.
  • The Dual Path Process gives owners a real ESOP price to hold against outside offers.
  • A downtown Chicago office plus several Midwest offices.

Cons

  • Owners set on a straightforward third-party sale may not need its ESOP capabilities.
  • Prairie does not publish a revenue or transaction-value range on the pages we reviewed.

Pricing

Prairie does not publish its fees. ESOP and sale engagements are usually priced differently, so ask for both structures if you want the firm to run a dual path.

Chicago M&A Advisor Decision Factors

“Yes” means confirmed from public materials. “Ask” means the firm does not publish it, so confirm it in your first conversation. “No” means not the case.

Firm $2M-$75M revenue fit Principal access Fee structure Chicago HQ Sector breadth
Salt Creek Advisory Yes: core focus Yes: founders lead every deal Yes: no retainer; success fee at closing Yes Focused: selected sectors
Amherst Partners Ask: range undisclosed Ask: confirm staffing Ask: not public No: Birmingham, Michigan Yes: broad
Caber Hill Advisors Ask: range undisclosed Ask: confirm staffing Ask: not public Yes Focused: four industry groups
Dresner Partners Ask: range undisclosed Ask: confirm staffing Ask: not public Yes Yes: broad
Lincoln International Ask: upper end Ask: deal dependent Ask: not public Yes Yes: broad
Peakstone Group Ask: $10M revenue floor Ask: confirm staffing Ask: not public Yes Yes: broad
Prairie Capital Advisors Ask: range undisclosed Ask: confirm staffing Ask: not public No: Oakbrook Terrace, with a Chicago office Yes: broad, ESOP specialist

How Should You Choose a Chicago M&A Advisor?

  1. Start with deal size. Compare your revenue and expected transaction value with each firm’s stated range. Salt Creek publishes a range of $2 million to $75 million in revenue, while Peakstone publishes a range beginning at $10 million; Lincoln does not disclose a standard range. Ask Amherst, Caber Hill, Dresner and Prairie to confirm fit because none of them publishes a clear range.
  2. Check relevant industry experience. An advisor who knows your sector can identify likely buyers and explain the operating factors that affect valuation. Salt Creek may fit businesses in its named focus sectors, while Lincoln offers broad global coverage. Caber Hill names healthcare, industrial, facility services and business services, and Prairie is the specialist if an ESOP is on the table. Review recent transactions when assessing Dresner, Peakstone, or Amherst.
  3. Decide how much principal access you want. Salt Creek gives owners direct access to Jack and Connor throughout the engagement. Larger firms may provide deeper staffing, but you should ask who will lead buyer outreach and negotiations after the initial pitch.
  4. Compare fee structures. Salt Creek’s standard engagements use a success fee with no retainer and no monthly fee; some start with a small deposit, credited against the success fee at closing. That is not the norm: the 2023-24 US Firmex M&A Fee Guide found that three-quarters of advisors charge some sort of engagement fee, and 54% said they credited the engagement fees paid towards the success fee. Ask every firm for its full engagement terms rather than one percentage.
  5. Consider geographic fit last. Salt Creek and Dresner have Chicago headquarters, as do Caber Hill, Lincoln and Peakstone. Prairie is headquartered in Oakbrook Terrace with a downtown office. Amherst serves the region without a confirmed Chicago office. Local presence can help with in-person meetings, but buyer reach and transaction experience usually carry more weight.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do M&A advisors typically charge?

A success fee is paid when a transaction closes, and 2023 to 2024 U.S. fee guide figures modeled fees of 6.3% at $5 million, 3.9% at $20 million, and 2.0% at $100 million. Salt Creek charges no retainer and no monthly fee for standard M&A engagements and is paid a success fee at closing. Some engagements start with a small deposit, credited against the success fee at closing. Comparing minimum fees, expenses, retainers, and the definition of transaction value reveals the total potential cost.

How does a business broker differ from an M&A advisor?

A business broker often markets smaller companies through listing networks, while an M&A advisor usually prepares detailed materials and contacts selected strategic and financial buyers. Salt Creek runs targeted sell-side processes for established founder-owned and family-owned businesses. You should choose based on transaction complexity and the buyers your company can attract.

How can I tell if an advisory firm is right-sized for my deal?

A right-sized advisor regularly serves companies near your revenue, earnings, and expected transaction-value profile. Salt Creek generally serves businesses with $2 million to $75 million in revenue and at least $500,000 of adjusted EBITDA. Confirming comparable engagements, assigned staff, and senior attention helps determine whether your deal will be a priority.

Do I need an advisor headquartered in Chicago?

Geographic fit reflects the advisor’s knowledge of regional buyers and the local business network. Salt Creek works nationally while maintaining its Chicago and Midwest base. You can prioritize sector knowledge and deal-size experience over office location if the advisor communicates well and can reach the right buyers.

See Whether Salt Creek Advisory Fits

Salt Creek is the right first call for founder-owned Chicago-area companies with $2 million to $75 million in revenue that want the founders running their sale and no retainer.

You do not need to be ready to sell. You can explore whether Salt Creek Advisory fits through a confidential conversation with Jack and Connor about valuation, buyer interest, timing, or unsolicited offers.

Sources