TL;DR
  • When your business partner wants out, read the operating or shareholder agreement first. Its buy-sell terms usually decide who may buy, how the price is set, and how fast it is paid.
  • There are three paths: the remaining partners buy the stake, all partners sell the whole company, or the departing partner sells the stake to an outside investor.
  • Selling the whole company usually brings the most per share, because the buyer gets control. A stake sold on its own usually takes a discount for lack of control and marketability.
  • Internal buyouts are faster and private, but they are often paid partly with a seller note, so the departing partner keeps carrying the risk of a business they no longer run.
  • In our illustrative example, a departing 40% partner nets $0.64 million more after tax, and about $2.9 million more at closing, from a whole-company sale than from a buyout paid partly with a note.
  • Entity type and deal structure change the tax bill. Bring in your own lawyer and a CPA before anyone names a price.

What should you do first when a business partner wants out?

When a business partner wants out, whether you are leaving or staying, read the operating agreement or shareholder agreement before anyone names a price, then get a current view of what the whole company is worth. The agreement often already decides who may buy the stake, how the price is set, and how quickly it must be paid.

Then name the reason. Retirement, burnout, a dispute, a divorce, a death or a disability each points to a different path and timetable.

  1. Collect the documents: the agreements, every amendment, and any life insurance tied to them.
  2. Find the trigger that applies and what the agreement requires for it.

What is a buy-sell agreement, and what does yours say?

A buy-sell agreement is a contract among the owners of a private company that says who may or must buy an owner’s interest when set events happen, such as retirement, death, disability, divorce or a dispute, and how the price is set.

  • Right of first refusal. Before an owner sells to an outsider, the company or the other owners may buy on the same terms as the outside offer.
  • Drag-along right. Owners holding a set majority can require the minority to join a sale of the whole company on the same terms.
  • Tag-along right. A minority owner can join a sale by the majority on the same terms.
  • Shotgun clause. One owner names a price and the other must either buy at that price or sell at it. It sounds fair, but it favors whichever partner can raise the cash.
  • Transfer restrictions. Even without a consent clause, Delaware’s LLC Act says the buyer of a member’s interest “shall have no right to participate in the management” unless the LLC agreement allows it or all members consent (6 Del. C. § 18-702).

Should you do a partner buyout or sell the whole company?

Choose a buyout when the remaining owners want to run the business for years and it can carry the debt. Sell the whole company when no one wants to stay long term, when the buyout would strain the balance sheet, or when the partners would rather share a control price (what a buyer pays to own all of it) than argue over a discounted one.

If you are the partner leaving, the whole-company sale usually pays you more, and more of it at closing.

PathProsConsTypical price outcomeTypical timeline
Internal buyout by the other partner(s) or the companyPrivate, faster, no outside diligencePart of the price is often a seller note, so the departing partner stays exposedSet by formula or appraisal; often below pro rata if discounts applyWeeks to a few months if the agreement is clear
Sell the whole company to a third partyControl price, mostly cash at closing, a clean breakAll owners must agree or be dragged along; remaining partners give up the business unless they roll equityUsually the highest value per share, split pro rataSix to nine months from hiring an advisor to closing when well run
Sell only the departing stake to an outside investorRemaining partners keep controlFew buyers want minority stakes; consent and first-refusal rights can block itUsually a discount to pro rata valueSeveral months, less predictable
Free Valuation Range

About a dozen quick questions and two minutes get you a ballpark range for your business, built from published industry transaction multiple ranges, with the math behind it. It is a directional estimate, not a formal valuation.

Value My Business

In a whole-company sale the remaining partner can keep a stake through rollover equity. Our guide to ESOP, private equity and strategic buyers compares those routes.

Why does a partner’s stake sell for less than its share of the company?

A stake that cannot control the company or be resold easily is usually worth less per share than the same slice of a company sold whole. Appraisers express this as a discount for lack of control and a discount for lack of marketability, applied to the stake’s pro rata value.

The IRS’s own valuation guidelines tell its appraisers to weigh “marketability, or lack thereof” and the “ability of the appraised interest to control the operation, sale, or liquidation of the relevant business” (Internal Revenue Manual 4.48.4.2.3). An IRS job aid for valuation staff reports that pre-IPO studies have shown average discounts “of around 40% to 45%,” with “substantial dispersion.” The job aid says it is not an official IRS position, so treat those figures as a sign of scale, not a benchmark.

In a whole-company sale those discounts usually disappear, because each partner sells part of a controlling block. In an internal buyout, your agreement’s standard of value decides. Fair market value, as the Supreme Court quoted the tax regulation in Connelly, is “the price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller.” Because a willing buyer pays less for a minority stake, that standard usually lets discounts in. Other agreements specify a pro rata share with no discounts. Illinois law takes that view when a court orders a corporation’s shares bought: “fair value” means the shareholder’s proportionate interest, “without any discount for minority status or, absent extraordinary circumstances, lack of marketability” (805 ILCS 5/12.56(e)). So before you negotiate, find the phrase your agreement uses.

How is a partner buyout paid for?

A departing partner is commonly paid from a mix of company cash, a bank or SBA loan taken by the buyer, and a seller note: a promissory note from the buyer to the departing partner, paid over several years.

If the buyer finances with an SBA loan, its rules shape how much cash you get at closing. For SBA applications given a loan number on or after October 1, 2026, SOP 50 10 8.1, Appendix 15, treats a buyout among existing owners as an “Owner Buyout”:

  • Who can buy. Remaining owners or employees buying another owner’s entire interest “must have been actively participating in the business operations for at least the last 24 consecutive months.”
  • Size and term. A standard 7(a) loan is capped at $5,000,000, and a loan that finances a change of ownership may not amortize over more than 10 years, except for qualifying real estate.
  • Equity. The minimum equity injection is 10%, but for Owner Buyouts the lender “may reduce or eliminate this requirement” if the business has enough liquidity and working capital.
  • Appraisal cap. Above a $350,000 price, or between closely related parties, the lender must order a business valuation from an accredited, independent appraiser (a “Qualified Source”) and may not use one prepared for the buyer or seller. If the price is higher, “the difference must be made up by equity.”
  • Seller notes. A seller note counts toward equity only if it is “on full standby,” meaning no principal or interest for the term of the SBA loan.
  • No earnouts. “Seller earnouts are prohibited.”
  • Partial exits. A selling owner who keeps less than 20% must personally guarantee the whole loan for at least two years after final disbursement.

A departing partner holding a note should negotiate like a lender: security, a personal guarantee, and acceleration if the company is later sold. Also ask to be released from your personal guarantees on company loans and leases, or indemnified where a lender or landlord refuses. Our guide to seller notes covers the terms, and our guide to earnouts and escrows explains why contingent money should be valued at a discount.

What goes wrong with buy-sell agreement valuation clauses?

Buy-sell price clauses commonly go wrong in four ways: a fixed price nobody updated, a book-value formula that ignores goodwill, an undefined standard of value, or one price for every trigger.

  • A stale fixed price. Many agreements set a value to be reset every year. When no one resets it, a number from years ago binds you.
  • Book value. Book value, assets minus liabilities at mostly historical cost, leaves out goodwill the company built itself, which for a services company can be nearly all of what a buyer pays.
  • An undefined standard. “Value,” “fair market value” and “fair value” can mean different things, and the difference often decides whether discounts apply.
  • One price for every trigger. Death, voluntary exit and termination for cause usually deserve different prices and payment terms.

See our guide to pricing a business.

How is selling your share of a business taxed?

Usually as a long-term capital gain, if the sale qualifies as a sale of a capital asset held over a year. Whether it does depends on the entity type (C corporation, S corporation, or LLC taxed as a partnership) and on whether the company buys back the stake (a redemption) or the other owners buy it directly.

SituationWhat it means for youThe rule behind it
The corporation buys back your shares (a redemption)A partial redemption by a C corporation can be taxed as a dividend instead of a capital gainA redemption is treated as a sale only if a test in 26 U.S.C. § 302(b) is met, such as a “complete redemption of all of the stock of the corporation owned by the shareholder”; otherwise it is a distribution under § 302(d)
Relatives still own shares (family attribution)A family partner who stays on the payroll can lose sale treatmentRelatives’ shares can count as yours; the waiver for a complete exit requires, among other conditions, that you keep no interest, “including an interest as officer, director, or employee,” except as a creditor, and acquire none for 10 years
Your partners buy your corporate shares directly (a cross-purchase)The buyer gets basis for a later sale; a redemption does not give remaining owners that basisThe buying partner’s basis in the shares is their cost (§ 1012)
The company is an LLC taxed as a partnershipPart of the gain can be taxed at ordinary ratesMoney received for the share of “unrealized receivables” and “inventory items” is treated as from the sale of a non-capital asset (§ 751(a))
You are paid over time (an installment sale)A seller note spreads the tax, but in a sale of depreciable assets the recapture is taxed in the year of sale (IRS Topic 705)Gain is reported as payments arrive, in proportion to gross profit over contract price (§ 453(c))
The seller note is very largeBig seller notes cost more to deferAn interest charge applies when notes from sales over $150,000 that arose in the year exceed $5,000,000 at year end (§ 453A)

The top federal rate on most long-term capital gain is 20%, with higher maximum rates for a few kinds of gain (IRS Topic 409). The 3.8% net investment income tax can apply on top above $250,000 of modified adjusted gross income for joint filers ($200,000 single). The IRS says it reaches stock gains but generally not gains from selling an active partnership or S corporation interest (IRS Topic 559). See our guides to minimizing taxes on a sale and asset vs. stock sales.

What did the Supreme Court decide in Connelly v. United States?

In Connelly v. United States (2024), a unanimous Supreme Court held that a company’s contractual obligation to redeem a deceased owner’s shares at fair market value is not necessarily a liability that reduces the company’s value. Life insurance the company collects to fund that redemption counts as a company asset when the shares are valued for federal estate tax. It matters if company-owned life insurance funds your buyout of an owner who dies.

Two brothers owned Crown C Supply, which carried $3.5 million of life insurance on each of them to fund a redemption. When Michael Connelly, who owned 77.18%, died, his estate reported his shares at $3 million. The IRS counted the insurance proceeds in the company’s value, put the company at $6.86 million and the shares at $5.3 million, and assessed an additional $889,914 in tax. The Court affirmed. It noted that a cross-purchase agreement, in which owners insure each other directly, would have kept the proceeds out of the company, though that structure has drawbacks of its own. If a partner has already died, our guide to selling a business after an owner dies covers who can sign and how the estate is taxed.

What if the partners are deadlocked?

If partners cannot agree and the agreement has no tie-breaker, the last resort is a court. State law lets a court dissolve a deadlocked company and, in some states, order a buyout instead. Try mediation first: litigation is slow, public and expensive.

  • Delaware LLCs. The Court of Chancery may dissolve an LLC “whenever it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with a limited liability company agreement” (6 Del. C. § 18-802).
  • Delaware 50/50 corporations. Where two 50% stockholders in a joint venture cannot agree on ending it, either may petition the Court of Chancery unless the charter or a written agreement says otherwise (8 Del. C. § 273).
  • Illinois corporations. A court may grant relief when directors are deadlocked, shareholders cannot break the deadlock, and the business “can no longer be conducted to the general advantage of the shareholders.” If the petition seeks a buyout, the company or other shareholders may elect to buy the petitioner’s shares “for their fair value” (805 ILCS 5/12.56).
  • Illinois LLCs. The court may order “a buyout of the applicant’s distributional interest” instead of dissolution (805 ILCS 180/35-1).

How do you keep the business stable while a partner exits?

Keep the exit confidential until terms are agreed, decide who will take over each customer, employee and supplier relationship the departing partner holds, and agree on one message and one timetable. See our guide to telling employees about a sale.

  • Protect the business. Include a non-solicitation and, where enforceable, a non-compete in the buyout. Our non-compete guide explains what courts accept.
  • Check third-party consents. Loans, leases, licenses and large customer contracts can contain change-of-ownership clauses.

Worked example: buyout vs. selling the whole company, after tax

This example is illustrative; the figures are assumptions, not market data. An S corporation earns $4 million of EBITDA on $30 million of revenue, has no debt, and is worth $20 million (5.0x EBITDA). Partner A owns 60%. Partner B owns 40%, has a $400,000 tax basis, and wants out. We treat every path as a sale of stock, apply a 20% federal capital gains rate, and ignore state tax, the net investment income tax, interest on the note and the costs of a buyout.

Partner B’s 40%Internal buyout with seller noteWhole-company saleStake sold to an outside investor
Pricing basisAppraised with discounts, negotiated to 15% below pro rata40% of $20M, less 5% sale costsAssumed 30% discount to pro rata
Price$6.80M$7.60M$5.60M
Paid at closing$4.00M (bank loan), plus $2.80M note over 5 years$7.60M$5.60M
Gain$6.40M$7.20M$5.20M
Federal tax at 20%$1.28M$1.44M$1.04M
After-tax proceeds$5.52M$6.16M$4.56M
After-tax cash at closingAbout $3.25M$6.16M$4.56M

The math behind the buyout column: under the installment method, 94.1% of each payment is gain ($6.4M of gain over a $6.8M price). The $4.0M at closing carries $3.76M of gain and $0.75M of tax, leaving about $3.25M. The $2.8M note is under the § 453A threshold, so no interest charge applies.

The whole-company sale leaves Partner B $0.64 million more after tax and about $2.9 million more in hand at closing, with no note riding on a business they no longer run. Partner A receives $11.4 million before tax instead of taking on $4.0 million of debt and a note. Real sales add escrows and working-capital adjustments that defer part of the price.

Which path fits? A decision checklist

QuestionIf yes, lean toward
Does the remaining partner want to run the company for at least five more years?Internal buyout
Can the company service buyout debt and still invest?Internal buyout
Is the departing partner unwilling to carry a note?Whole-company sale
Is the remaining partner also within a few years of retiring?Whole-company sale
Does a majority hold a drag-along right?Whole-company sale is available even without unanimity
Is the relationship too strained to run a sale process together?Mediation, then a buyout with a fixed timetable

How long does each path take?

A well-run sale of the whole company takes six to nine months from hiring an advisor to closing. An internal buyout can close faster when the agreement sets the price and the buyer has financing, but a disputed price, a lender’s underwriting, or a deadlock in court can stretch it well past a full sale.

SBA financing adds the lender’s independent valuation, but SOP 50 10 8.1 does not require a quality of earnings report for Owner Buyouts, because the existing owners “retain operational knowledge of the business.”

What to do this month

  1. Week 1: read the documents. Pull every agreement and amendment, and list each trigger, price clause and consent right.
  2. Week 1: agree on confidentiality. Put in writing that the talks stay between the partners and their advisors.
  3. Week 2: hire your own lawyer. Each partner needs one; company counsel represents the company.
  4. Week 2: update the numbers. Close the books through last month and update adjusted EBITDA.
  5. Weeks 3 and 4: price the whole company. Get an indication of what it would bring in a sale, so a buyout price has a reference point, and have the CPA model the tax on each path.
  6. If company-owned life insurance funds the agreement, ask estate counsel about Connelly.

Family-owned? See our succession planning guide.

What this guide cannot tell you

No public dataset tracks how private partner exits resolve, so the comparison table and the buyout and minority-sale timelines are our judgment. SBA rules change; these are from SOP 50 10 8.1. We cite only Delaware and Illinois law.

How Salt Creek Advisory helps partners decide

We represent owners selling their companies, never buyers. When partners decide together to sell the whole company, we run the sale for all of them. Before that decision, we can show what the company would likely bring in a sale, so a buyout can be weighed against it before anyone signs.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if my business partner wants out and there is no buy-sell agreement? Neither partner can usually force the other to buy or sell, so you negotiate a price and terms. If talks fail, state law may let a court dissolve the company or order a buyout.

Can my partner force me to sell the whole business? It depends on your agreement and your ownership. A drag-along clause can require you to join a sale, and in a Delaware corporation a sale of all or substantially all assets needs board approval and a majority of the outstanding voting stock, not unanimity (8 Del. C. § 271). A court can also order dissolution or a buyout under state law.

How is a partner’s share of a business valued? Start with the value of the whole company, subtract debt, and take the partner’s percentage. Then apply whatever the agreement requires: a formula, an appraisal, and discounts for lack of control and marketability if its standard of value allows them.

Can I use an SBA loan to buy out my business partner? Often, yes. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, a 7(a) loan can fund an Owner Buyout, and owners or employees buying another owner’s entire interest must have actively participated in the business for at least the last 24 consecutive months. Seller earnouts are prohibited.

Do I pay capital gains tax when I sell my share of a business? Usually, if the sale qualifies as a sale of a capital asset held over a year. A partial redemption by a C corporation can be taxed as a dividend, and in an LLC taxed as a partnership part of the gain tied to receivables and inventory can be ordinary income.

Sources