- What to do when a business sale falls through, in order: get the buyer’s reason in writing, have counsel read what your letter of intent still binds, demand your confidential materials back, fix what broke the deal, then call the runner-up bidders.
- You usually cannot force a buyer to close, because most letters of intent bind only confidentiality, exclusivity and a few other terms. Delaware courts have awarded damages when a party broke a signed promise to negotiate in good faith, so check your wording.
- Advisors blame financing most: 35% of 354 attorneys, bankers and CPAs in BNY Wealth’s 2026 survey named it. Real broken deals point to diligence: of 75 Axial-sourced LOIs that broke in 2025, diligence findings caused 25.3%, EBITDA gaps found by a quality of earnings review 21.3%, and financing 10.7%.
- A price cut after diligence, called a re-trade, is fair when it equals a verified EBITDA change times your LOI multiple, and tactical when it does not. In our illustrative example, accepting a $20.0 million re-trade is worth about $19.8 million in expected proceeds against $18.2 million for relaunching.
- To keep the next deal from failing, commission a sell-side quality of earnings report, hold exclusivity to 30 to 45 days, demand financing proof, and set the working capital number in the LOI.
What should you do in the first 72 hours after a sale falls through?
In the first 72 hours, get the termination in writing, read which terms of your letter of intent still bind both sides, demand the return or destruction of your confidential materials, and decide who inside the company needs to hear what. Do not sign a new exclusivity letter yet.
This guide is for owners of companies with roughly $5 million to $75 million of revenue whose buyer walked away, or cut the price, after a letter of intent (LOI) or during diligence. An LOI is the short document recording the main terms a buyer proposes before lawyers draft the purchase agreement.
- Get it in writing. Ask the buyer to confirm by email that it is ending talks, and the reason. The date matters for exclusivity, and the reason tells your next buyers what to test.
- Send the file to your lawyer. Have deal counsel read the LOI, the nondisclosure agreement (NDA) and any signed purchase agreement the same day.
- Demand your materials back. Send a written request under the NDA for the return or destruction of everything the buyer received, and ask for written certification.
- Tell a small circle. Brief only the managers who knew about the deal. Give them one consistent line: the company explored options and is staying focused on customers.
- Watch for leaks. If customers or employees heard about the sale, answer questions calmly and briefly. Our guide on telling employees about a sale covers the wording.
- Hold off on a new LOI. Do not give another buyer exclusivity until you know why the first deal died.
What does your letter of intent still bind after the buyer walks?
Usually only a handful of provisions: confidentiality, exclusivity, and governing law and venue. The price and deal terms are normally non-binding, so the buyer can walk without paying you anything unless the documents say otherwise. Mintz, a law firm, writes that an LOI “generally should be nonbinding” but that “it is common for a few provisions of the LOI to be binding.”
| Provision | What to check today | What is typical |
|---|---|---|
| Exclusivity (no-shop) | End date, and whether the buyer’s termination ends it at once | Mintz: 30 to 45 days. Beresford Booth: 60 to 90 days |
| Confidentiality and NDA | How long it survives; return-or-destroy clause | Survives the deal’s collapse |
| Employee non-solicit | Whether the buyer may hire your people, and for how long | DLA Piper’s blog: six months to two years, one year common |
| Termination or breakup fee | Whether any fee exists and what triggers it | Rare; 83% of 2025 deals in SRS Acquiom’s study had none |
| Deposit | Whether one was paid and whether it is refundable | Uncommon, in our view; read your own terms |
| Good-faith negotiation | Any promise to “negotiate in good faith” | Breach can bring damages in Delaware (see below) |
About a dozen quick questions and two minutes get you a ballpark range for your business, built from published industry transaction multiple ranges, with the math behind it. It is a directional estimate, not a formal valuation.
Value My BusinessA breakup fee, also called a termination fee, is money one side pays if the deal does not close. In SRS Acquiom’s 2026 Deal Terms Study of private-target acquisitions that closed in 2025, 83% of purchase agreements had no termination fee and 14% had one payable by the buyer. Those are signed purchase agreements for deals of all sizes, not LOIs.
The NDA usually does the most work now. A 2012 guide on DLA Piper’s Venture Alley blog tells the disclosing party to confirm the NDA provides for “the return or destruction” of written confidential information.
Why do business sales fall through?
Business sales most often fall through over diligence findings, earnings that do not hold up, or the buyer’s financing. In a BNY Wealth survey run by The Harris Poll in April 2026, 35% of 354 U.S. attorneys, investment bankers and CPAs named financing as the aspect most likely to make a typical private business sale fall through.
In the same survey, advisors rated only 48% of sellers as prepared when diligence begins. These are advisors’ opinions across deal sizes and industries, not counts of failed deals.
Counts of real broken deals point more to diligence. Axial’s Dead Deal Report on 75 Axial-sourced LOIs that broke in 2025 found diligence findings outside the quality of earnings review in 25.3%, EBITDA discrepancies found by that review in 21.3% (up from 10.6% in 2023), renegotiation in 14.7%, the seller’s decision in 13.3%, financing in 10.7% and business underperformance in 8.0%. Those deals sat under exclusivity for months first: an average of 106 days with private equity buyers and 129 days with independent sponsors.
Nancy Stabell, an M&A attorney writing for ACG’s Middle Market Growth in March 2026, lists five post-LOI breakdowns from her own practice: EBITDA that does not hold up, which she calls the most common; non-financial diligence surprises; financing fragility; re-trades and deal fatigue; and seller unpreparedness. EBITDA means earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, the profit figure most buyers price.
What this means for you: find the row below that matches why your deal died, and fix that before any new buyer sees the business.
| Cause | Warning sign | How to prevent it |
|---|---|---|
| Financing failure | No lender named in the LOI; vague “subject to financing” | Ask for a lender letter or proof of equity before exclusivity |
| Quality of earnings findings | Large or undocumented add-backs; cash-basis books | Commission a sell-side quality of earnings report |
| Customer concentration | One customer with a large share of revenue; contracts not assignable | Disclose it up front; document renewals and assignment terms |
| Working capital dispute | The LOI says “normal level” with no number | Set the working capital peg in the LOI |
| Owner dependence | You hold the key customer and supplier relationships | Build a second layer of management; see our owner dependence guide |
| Environmental or legal issues | Owned real estate, past contamination, open lawsuits, unfiled sales tax | Order a Phase I environmental site assessment and a legal cleanup before launch |
| Buyer fatigue or a change of strategy | Slow replies, new deal team members, a platform deal elsewhere | Short exclusivity with milestones; keep backup bidders warm |
A working capital peg is the level of current assets minus current liabilities the buyer expects at closing; the price moves up or down from it. SRS Acquiom reports in its 2026 working capital study that, in private-target deals, these adjustments appear in “more than 90% of transactions today, up from 50% just a decade ago.”
Is a re-trade after due diligence legitimate or tactical?
A re-trade is a buyer lowering the price, or worsening the terms, after signing the LOI. It is legitimate when it rests on a specific, documented finding that changes earnings or risk, and the cut is sized to that finding. It is tactical when it arrives late in exclusivity with a vague reason and a round number.
The law firm Beresford Booth warns sellers that if a buyer decides to “walk away, re-price, or restructure the deal after weeks of due diligence,” you have “lost time and momentum with other interested parties.” In our view, a tactical re-trade counts on that lost leverage.
| Test | Points to legitimate | Points to tactical |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence | A written finding you can check, such as a QoE schedule | “Market conditions” or “our committee” |
| Size | The cut equals the EBITDA change times the LOI multiple | A round number unrelated to any finding |
| Timing | Soon after the finding | Days before exclusivity ends or closing |
| Disclosure | The issue was not in your data room | You disclosed it before the LOI |
| Flexibility | Open to structure, such as an earnout or escrow | Take it or leave it |
Size is the cleanest test. If the LOI paid 6.0 times EBITDA and diligence removes $500,000 of EBITDA, a $3.0 million cut is consistent with the original deal. A $4.0 million cut is a new price.
What this means for you: divide the cut by your LOI multiple. If the result far exceeds any EBITDA change the buyer can document, it is a negotiating move.
Should you accept a re-trade, counter, or walk away?
Accept when the finding is real and your alternatives are slow; counter with structure when the risk is real but uncertain; walk away when the cut is tactical and you have bidders ready. Compare each path on expected proceeds and time to cash, not on the headline price you lost.
Answer each question yes or no for your own deal. The answer with the most yes rows is your starting position.
| Question | If yes, leans |
|---|---|
| Would your own accountant confirm the buyer’s finding? | Accept |
| Have your runner-up bidders moved on or bought something else? | Accept |
| Are this year’s results softer than the numbers buyers saw? | Accept |
| Does the cut rest on something time will prove, such as a customer renewal? | Counter with structure |
| Will the buyer discuss an earnout or escrow for the disputed amount? | Counter with structure |
| Is the cut much larger than the EBITDA change times your LOI multiple? | Walk away |
| Did you disclose the issue before you signed the LOI? | Walk away |
| Is at least one credible bidder still interested today? | Walk away |
To counter with structure, offer part of the gap as an earnout or escrow tied to that exact risk. Our deal structuring guide covers the protections to ask for.
Here is an illustrative example, not a client deal. A company has $4.0 million of adjusted EBITDA and signed an LOI at 6.0x, or $24.0 million. Its quality of earnings review confirmed the EBITDA, but near the end of exclusivity the buyer cuts to $20.0 million, citing customer concentration you disclosed up front. Our assumptions, all judgment:
- accepting closes in about 2 months with a 90% chance; if it fails, you relaunch;
- relaunching takes about 7 more months and costs $100,000 for an updated sell-side review;
- a relaunch has a 50% chance of $24.0 million, a 30% chance of $21.0 million from buyers who discount a deal that broke, and a 20% chance of no acceptable offer in that window, counted here as zero proceeds.
| Line | Accept the re-trade | Relaunch |
|---|---|---|
| Main outcome | 90% × $20.0M = $18.00M | 50% × $24.0M = $12.00M |
| Second outcome | 10% × relaunch value $18.20M = $1.82M | 30% × $21.0M = $6.30M |
| Cost of a new sell-side review | None | −$0.10M |
| Expected proceeds | $19.82M | $18.20M |
| Time to most of the cash | About 2 months | About 7 months or more |
Relaunch value = $12.00M + $6.30M − $0.10M = $18.20M. Accept value = $18.00M + $1.82M = $19.82M. Accepting wins by $1.62 million in expectation, and the cash arrives about five months sooner.
Break-even: relaunching must be worth $20.0 million to match the buyer’s new price. With the 30% chance of $21.0 million held fixed, that needs $24.0M × p + $6.30M − $0.10M = $20.0M, so p = $13.8M ÷ $24.0M = 57.5%. Swap in your own EBITDA, multiple and odds. The math ignores what the business earns while you wait, and that you still own the company if no offer comes; both favor relaunching, more so if earnings are rising.
Countering often beats both. If the buyer pays $21.0 million at closing plus a $3.0 million earnout on that customer renewing, you split the disputed risk instead of pricing it at the buyer’s worst case.
Can you sue a buyer who backed out after the LOI?
Rarely with success, because the price and deal terms in most LOIs are non-binding. You may have a claim if the buyer broke a binding term, such as confidentiality, the employee non-solicit, or a written promise to negotiate in good faith. Have deal counsel read the exact wording before you threaten anything.
Delaware treats a good-faith promise as real. In Cox Communications v. T-Mobile (2022), the Delaware Supreme Court said parties to such agreements “must negotiate the open terms in good faith, but they are not required to make a deal.” In SIGA Technologies v. PharmAthene, a 2015 decision over a license term sheet whose footer read “Non Binding Terms,” the court affirmed $113 million of expectation damages, the profit the deal would have produced.
Damages can also be far smaller. In Postbit v. Look Dynamics, a May 2026 letter decision on a term sheet for a $38 million to $65 million merger, the Court of Chancery had already dismissed the request to force the deal through. After Look Dynamics failed to hire counsel and lost on liability by default, the court awarded reliance damages of $360,605.12, the money Postbit had paid Look Dynamics, plus attorneys’ fees, and denied expectation damages. In that case the walking party was the company being acquired, so these duties can bind you too.
How do you go back to market after a deal fell through?
Start with the runner-up bidders, fix the problem that broke the deal, and relaunch with a short, honest explanation. Buyers who bid recently already know the business, so they can move faster than new ones, though they will ask why the deal died and may bid lower to account for it.
What this means for you: keep every runner-up offer on file, as our guide to comparing letters of intent recommends, and call those bidders only once you can name the fix.
- Explain it in one paragraph. Say what the buyer found or why it left, and what you have done since. If the buyer’s financing failed, say so plainly.
- Fix first. If earnings were the issue, a sell-side quality of earnings report comes before anything else. If it was a contract, a lawsuit or sales tax, clean it up and document the fix.
- Refresh the numbers. Update the financials and forecast to current results.
A business that sits on the market for months invites buyers to ask what others found, so relaunch as a short, focused competitive auction.
A well-run sale takes six to nine months from hiring an advisor to closing. Surveys run longer: the IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse survey for Q2 2026 reports lower middle market deals, across industries, averaged 11 to 12 months from engagement to close. In our judgment, not from any dataset, a relaunch adds four to seven months, because your materials and buyer list already exist.
How do you keep the next deal from falling through?
Run a competitive process with live backup bidders, test your earnings before buyers do, and negotiate the terms that cause fights into the LOI itself. Most causes in the table above can be found and fixed before a buyer signs.
- Keep backups and get financing proof. Sign with one buyer only after several have bid and shown a lender’s letter or committed equity, and keep the others informed through exclusivity.
- Commission a sell-side quality of earnings report. GF Data, as reported in ACG’s Middle Market Growth in fall 2025, found, across 360 deals completed since Q3 2024, that sellers that used one saw 7.4x TEV/EBITDA on average against 7.0x for those that did not, with the benefit most notable above $50 million of enterprise value and smaller deals tending not to see a valuation boost. The review’s main job below that size is avoiding surprises. Advisors quoted there suggest starting three to six months before a sale.
- Shorten exclusivity. Mintz suggests sellers agree to 30 to 45 days and limit automatic extensions “to one.” Tie any extension to milestones, such as a draft purchase agreement, and write that exclusivity ends if the buyer lowers the price.
- Set the working capital peg in the LOI. Agree on a number or a formula, not “a normal level.”
- Disclose problems early. An issue revealed before the LOI is priced into the bid. The same issue found in diligence becomes a re-trade. Our due diligence checklist shows what buyers will request.
What to do this month
Protect your information, learn exactly why the deal broke, and decide on facts whether to accept, counter or relaunch.
- Collect the LOI, NDA, any purchase agreement draft and the buyer’s termination note in one folder.
- Request written confirmation that the buyer returned or destroyed your materials, and mark the non-solicit end date on your calendar.
- Ask the buyer’s deal lead for a call, and write down every finding they cite, with the dollar amount each one moved.
- Check each finding against your own books, with your existing CPA, before you accept it as true.
- Run the size test and the yes-or-no table above with your own EBITDA, multiple and offer.
- List your runner-up bidders and what each offered, and draft the one-paragraph explanation you will give them.
- Talk to deal counsel and a sell-side advisor about whether to counter, accept or relaunch before you reply to the buyer in writing.
What this guide cannot tell you
No public dataset counts how often lower middle market LOIs fail or how large re-trades are. The BNY figures are advisor opinions, not deal counts; Axial counts only deals from its own platform; and SRS Acquiom’s data covers closed deals of all sizes. The relaunch timeline and the example’s probabilities are our judgment. Whether you have a legal claim depends on your documents and your state’s law.
How we work with owners after a broken deal
Salt Creek Advisory represents sellers only, and Jack and Connor Pitts work directly on each engagement. If a buyer has walked or re-traded, we can review where the process stands and whether to counter or relaunch. Start a confidential conversation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue a buyer who backed out after signing a letter of intent?
Usually not over the price or deal terms, because most LOIs make those non-binding. You may have a claim if the buyer broke a binding term, such as confidentiality, a non-solicit, or a written promise to negotiate in good faith, which Delaware courts have enforced with damages. Have deal counsel read the exact wording first.
Can I keep the buyer’s deposit if the deal falls through?
Only if your documents say so. In our view, deposits are uncommon in lower middle market LOIs, and when they exist, the terms decide whether they are refundable. Termination fees are also rare: SRS Acquiom found none in 83% of 2025 deals in its study.
How long should exclusivity last?
The law firm Mintz suggests sellers agree to 30 to 45 days, with no more than one automatic extension. Another law firm, Beresford Booth, describes 60 to 90 days as typical. Shorter is better for you, and any extension should depend on milestones such as a draft purchase agreement.
Should I go back to the second-place bidder?
Often yes, because a recent bidder already knows your business and can move faster than a new buyer. Call only after you can explain why the first deal ended and what you fixed. Expect them to test the issue that broke the first deal.
Do I have to tell new buyers why the last deal fell through?
Your NDA with the first buyer may limit what you can say about it, so check with counsel. Buyers will ask anyway, and a short, honest explanation backed by a fix, such as a sell-side quality of earnings report, works better than silence that diligence will later expose.
Does a failed deal lower my business’s value?
Not by itself. Value follows earnings and risk, so a deal that failed over the buyer’s financing says little about your company. A deal that failed over your numbers will cost value until you fix and document the problem.
Sources
- BNY Wealth with The Harris Poll, Structuring the Sale: Insights for Private Business Owners, 2026. Online survey of 354 U.S. attorneys, investment bankers and CPAs, April 16 to 30, 2026. Opinions, not deal counts.
- SRS Acquiom, 2026 M&A Deal Terms Study. Private-target deals SRS Acquiom serviced that closed from 2020 through 2025, all industries and sizes.
- SRS Acquiom, 2026 Working Capital Purchase Price Adjustment Study.
- IBBA and M&A Source, Market Pulse Survey Q2 2026, press release. Survey of advisors on deals up to $50 million, all industries.
- Nancy Stabell, Why Middle-Market Deals Fail After the Term Sheet, ACG Middle Market Growth, March 11, 2026. One attorney’s experience.
- Axial, Dead Deal Report: Unpacking 2025’s Broken LOIs, January 27, 2026 (archived copy). 75 Axial-sourced LOIs that broke in 2025; Axial platform only.
- ACG Middle Market Growth, article on GF Data and sell-side quality of earnings reports, Fall 2025 issue, posted December 2, 2025.
- Mintz, Seller Considerations When Negotiating a Letter of Intent, March 31, 2025. Law firm commentary.
- Beresford Booth, The Letter of Intent Isn’t a Done Deal, June 30, 2026. Law firm commentary.
- DLA Piper, The Venture Alley, Reviewing the M&A Nondisclosure Agreement, August 14, 2012.
- Delaware courts: Cox Communications, Inc. v. T-Mobile US, Inc. (Del. March 3, 2022); SIGA Technologies, Inc. v. PharmAthene, Inc. (Del. December 23, 2015); Postbit, Inc. v. Look Dynamics, Inc. (Del. Ch. May 13, 2026).